Current location:sport >>
Offering a chair to older colleague at work could count as age discrimination, judge rules
sport5434People have gathered around
IntroductionOffering a chair to an older colleague at work could count as age discrimination, an employment judg ...
Offering a chair to an older colleague at work could count as age discrimination, an employment judge has ruled.
Being given the opportunity to sit while younger staff stand could lead to 'less favourable treatment', a tribunal concluded.
It means that any employer who offers a chair to elderly workers, rather than their younger peers, could be breaking equality laws as the older person could 'legitimately conclude' they were being treated 'disadvantageously'.
The ruling came after Filipe Edreira, a 66-year-old recycling plan operative, sued Severn Waste Water Service in Worcester after he was asked to sit down during his shift.
The employee, who had worked at the company for 17 years before he was sacked in October 2023, believed his employers were trying to force him out and claimed he was being singled out as no-one else at the site used chairs.
Filipe Edreira, a 66-year-old recycling plan operative, sued Seven Waste Water Service in Worcester after he was asked to sit down during his shift. Pictured: One of the Severn Waster Water service plants
His claim was dismissed as the tribunal found the chair had been offered as colleagues were worried for his health, the tribunal in Birmingham did agree the move 'unwanted conduct' that could have been discriminatory.
'Given that we found it was an unusual thing to do, in our judgment [Mr Edreira] could legitimately conclude that he was being treated differently to others and therefore disadvantageously,' Employment Judge David Faulkner said.
Of the 80 employees at the recycling plant, Mr Edreira was the only person aged over 66, although there were four over 60 and around half were 50 years of age or over.
He turned 66 on November 3, 2021, and wanted to work for another 18 months, it was heard.
In an email in July 2022, Mr Edreira - who could not carry out heavy lifting following surgery - said he had heard colleagues say they'd heard bosses 'encouraging people to retire at 66'.
He complained that in May 2022 he had been forced to move from the cabin that dealt with paper - which he had worked in for 10 years - to one which dealt with plastic.
Around the same time, his manager Idris Buraimoh 'asked him if he wanted a chair when he had not asked for one'.
The hearing was told: '[Mr Edreira] replied he did not want one. [Mr Buraimoh] did not give a reason for the offer, though there was nothing unpleasant or rude about the way in which he asked the question.
Offering a chair to an older colleague at work could count as age discrimination, an employment judge has ruled. Pictured: File photo of an older worker in a warehouse
'[Mr Edreira] told us he believes Mr Buraimoh was told to offer it - we assume by management - as part of SWS's aim to get him to leave as someone who had reached age 66.
'SWS says it is commonplace to offer appropriate support which will help employees be more comfortable at work and that chairs are routinely offered to those on light duties or feeling unwell.
'It says that because shifts are 10 hours long it is not uncommon for people to need to sit, and that chairs can also be offered long-term as an adjustment for health reasons.'
The hearing was told chairs are 'routinely offered to staff' who might find them beneficial, because of health or pregnancy, some would prefer not to use them, whilst others may use them from time to time.
However, Mr Edreira insisted employees were not allowed to sit down during their shifts and that he did not see anyone using a chair.
In July, he was wrongly issued with an AWOL letter accusing him of taking unauthorised absence from work. The same month he went off sick and in October he was sacked.
The now 68-year-old sued for age discrimination and harassment claiming the company had tried to force him out after he reached 66. However, the tribunal rejected his case.
Of the chair claim, EJ Faulkner said Mr Edreira's boss had been concerned with his health not his age.
'We concluded on balance that chairs were not routinely offered to employees in or around May 2022,' he said.
'The crucial question...was whether [Mr Edreira] had also proved facts from which we could conclude that the offer of the chair was because of age.
'[His] case was not that he was offered a chair because he was 'old' or 'older than most workers' but because he had reached age 66.
'It had never happened before and there was no explanation given for it, but we did not think that was sufficient of itself to indicate that him being over age 66 was in Mr Buraimoh's mind, consciously or otherwise, when he offered the chair.'
'We were told that Mr Buraimoh does not know why he offered the chair, but we thought that what was a much more likely explanation for the change of practice in this regard, namely that Mr Buraimoh had become aware of [his health condition] at the time of the cabin moves and offered the chair for that reason.'
Tags:
Reprint:Friends are welcome to share on the Internet, but please indicate the source of the article when reprinting it.“Global Gazetteer news portal”。http://panama.downmusic.org/content-90b799904.html
Related articles
Analysis: Larson enters conversation with Verstappen as best drivers in the world
sportINDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Ask almost any hardcore motorsports fan who the best driver in the world is righ ...
【sport】
Read moreRuapehu Alpine Lifts gets $7m bailout from government
sportRuapehu Alpine Lifts has been given $7 million from the government. Photo: Supplied/ Ruapehu Alpine ...
【sport】
Read moreFrom House Sparrows to Blue Tits: The stunning birds spotted the most often in UK gardens
sportSparrows, blue tits and starlings top the list of birds spotted in UK gardens this year –but some on ...
【sport】
Read more
Popular articles
- Medics remove 150 MAGGOTS from a woman's mouth after dental procedure left her with rotting tissue
- Sweet or savory? This is what your taste in snacks says about you, according to science
- What REALLY happened the night of OJ Simpson and Kris Jenner allegedly hooked up in the hot tub
- Who's a clever boy? Dogs excel in different intelligence tasks
- Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection after closing some restaurants
- Travellers share snaps of the worst behaved flight passengers
Latest articles
Strictly star Giovanni Pernice's former partner Rose Ayling
Why cat urine smells so bad: Scientists reveal what causes the unique stench
Fin Affleck's close friendship with JLo's child Emme Maribel Munniz, 16
Early man's best friend was the fox as the animal was domesticated by humans, research suggests
Trump accepts a VP debate but wants it on Fox News. Harris has already said yes to CBS
Michigan approves 'extremely toxic' copper mine just 100ft from Lake Superior
LINKS
- Heavy rain warning for Westland likely to move to red
- Israel scraps visit after US allows passage of Gaza ceasefire resolution
- Death of 8
- Major internet disruptions in west and central Africa
- Sean 'Diddy' Combs: What we know about the accusations against him
- Firearms Minister accused of misleading public on gun stats
- Chinese new energy industry contributes to global green, low
- Firearms Minister accused of misleading public on gun stats
- Climate strike expected to attract thousands
- Gulf Harbour body: Interpol 'black notice' issued one month after mystery discovery